Forum/General Discussion/Swapping oak for pine in this bookshelf plan, worth it?

Swapping oak for pine in this bookshelf plan, worth it?

#modification#furniture#help
cutlistavery1 replies0 likes
Original Post
Apr 26, 2026

Found a plan online for a pretty simple bookshelf but it calls for red oak throughout and that's just not in my budget right now. I'm thinking of swapping it all to #2 pine but the plan has some dadoes for the shelves and i'm wondering if pine will hold up or if the dadoes will just crush over time with book weight. Anyone done a full species swap like this on a plan before?

Apr 26, 2026

Pine dadoes will hold fine for books, just don't go too shallow on the depth.

Sign in to join this discussion.

Sign in to reply

Thread Info

CreatedApr 26, 2026
Replies1
Likes0